The employment law attorneys of Marshall Dennehey concentrate their practice on the representation of employers in all areas of employment-related litigation and counseling. Annually, our attorneys handle hundreds of employment matters for clients, including insurers and their insureds, self-insured Fortune 1000 companies, joint insurance funds, state governments and local municipalities. Litigation matters are handled in each of the jurisdictions in which we practice and cover the full range of employment-related claims under the relevant federal and state statutes and local ordinances. They include but are not limited to:
- Age discrimination claims under the Age Discrimination in Employment Act
- Sex, race, national origin and religion discrimination claims under Title VII
- Disability discrimination claims under the Americans with Disabilities Act
- Section 1981 and Section 1983 civil rights claims
- Common law wrongful discharge claims
- Employment-related defamation claims
- Claims under the Family and Medical Leave Act
- Claims under the Fair Labor Standards Act and similar state statutes
In addition to handling employment law litigation matters, we provide our clients with a full range of advisory services in order to help them avoid litigation. These services include but are not limited to:
- Staff training on employment-related topics at client’s location
- Review and/or draft employment handbooks
- Reviews of client employment policies/procedures
- Advise clients on their specific, breaking employment issues, as they arise
A significant strength of our firm is the regional representation we provide insurers and self-insureds. We have 19 offices and can handle employment matters throughout Pennsylvania, New Jersey, New York, Connecticut, Delaware, Ohio and Florida. The attorneys in the Employment Law Practice Group have the requisite local knowledge and experience to provide highly-skilled and effective representation to our clients who face employment-related litigation or have employment-related issues in any of those jurisdictions.
We always handle every case with a practical, result-oriented approach which balances strong representation of our clients with realistic cost containment. Our fees are very competitive, and we work with our clients to develop innovative alternative approaches to file handling and billing which oftentimes result in significant savings to our clients.
Results
Jury Defense Verdict Secured in High-Profile Employment Law Case in New Jersey
Defense Verdict Obtained in Two Consolidated Matters Following a Five-Day Trial
We obtained a defense verdict in two consolidated matters in the Eastern District of Pennsylvania following a five-day trial before Judge Gallagher. The first plaintiff alleged he was terminated in retaliation for filing a lawsuit and that he was subjected to racial discrimination during his employment. The second plaintiff alleged he was terminated in retaliation for supporting the wage and hour claims of the first plaintiff. After deliberating for approximately two hours, the jury answered “no” on the five theories asserted by the plaintiffs.
Thought Leadership
Case Law Alerts
Florida First DCA Clarifies Limits of Whistleblower and First Amendment Retaliation Claims by Public Employees
November 3, 2026
Earlier this year, Florida’s First District Court of Appeal affirmed summary judgment entered by the trial court in favor of Florida Department of Health and related individual defendants, in this whistleblower retaliation lawsuit arising from the Plaintiff/former employee’s (Rebekah Jones) work on the Department of Health’s public-facing COVID-19 data portal during the global pandemic. During the lawsuit, Jones claimed that she was terminated after refusing to alter COVID-19 data and that her actions constituted protected whistleblower activity. The First DCA disagreed, emphasizing that Florida’s Whistleblower’s Act requires an employee to make a qualifying disclosure of a violation of law or other prohibited conduct to an appropriate recipient at some point in time before the adverse employment action occurs. The court rejected Jones’ theory that the statute protects an employee from “preemptive retaliation,” which would be retaliation based on an anticipated future disclosure. The court also concluded that Jones’s statements about how she was being treated at work did not amount to a protected disclosure of a violation of law under the statute, and that her refusal to perform certain job duties likewise did not constitute protected activity. The First DCA also rejected Jones’ claim that she had a First Amendment retaliation claim because all of the pertinent communications were made during the course of Jones’ employment responsibilities, rather than as a private citizen. The Jones decision makes clear that an employee’s allegations of workplace wrongdoing, standing alone or raised too late, may not be enough to support a retaliation claim.
Case Law Alerts
Court Finds Employee Was Not a Qualified Individual Under the ADA
November 3, 2026
In Williams v. Walmart, Inc., Cameron Williams, proceeding pro se, alleged wrongful discharge due to disability and failure to accommodate under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), the Delaware Persons with Disabilities Employment Protections Act (DPDEPA) and retaliation under the Delaware workers' compensation law, against Walmart, after being terminated on September 17, 2022. Williams sustained a work-related low back injury on July 23, 2022, while working in a physically demanding role that required lifting up to 60 pounds, prolonged standing, and climbing. After his injury, he was given work restrictions and Walmart offered Williams several positions under its Temporary Alternate Duty (TAD) program to accommodate these medical restrictions. During the period June through September 2022, Williams accrued seven unauthorized absences. Under Walmart's Attendance Policy, accumulating five or more occurrences in a rolling six-month period subjects an employee to termination. Williams applied for a leave of absence through Walmart’s third-party administrator. The leave request was denied for lack of medical documentation. Williams was terminated for violating the attendance policy. The Court granted Walmart summary judgment on all claims. The disability and failure to accommodate claims failed because Williams admitted his medical restrictions prevented him from performing the essential functions of his prior position. The Court found that Williams was not a "qualified individual" under the ADA. Further, Walmart accommodated his restrictions by offering him several Alternate Duty positions. Williams workers' compensation retaliation claim failed because there was no evidence of a causal connection between Williams’ comp claim and his termination. The retaliation claims under the disability statutes also failed because filing a workers' compensation claim is not a protected activity. The Court also found that Williams’ leave of absence request was managed by a third-party administrator with no link to Walmart's personnel decisions. This is a positive case for Employers. Employers should: Maintain clear, written descriptions of the physically demanding requirements of each job (e.g., lifting limits, standing durations, and climbing requirements). This will assist the Court in evaluating whether a Plaintiff can perform the essential functions of the position. Offer temporary, modified roles that align with an employee's medical restrictions to show evidence of an employer's efforts to accommodate. Ongoing efforts to offer positions within any work restrictions will assist with insulating the Employer from failure-to-accommodate liability. Maintain neutral attendance policies and apply them consistently. This will provide evidence of a legitimate, nondiscriminatory reason for termination. When applied uniformly, this should prevent Plaintiffs from arguing that the policy was used as a pretext for discrimination. Use Third-Party Administrators for leave management. When a third party makes the leave decisions, this protects the Employer from retaliation claims. When a third party makes the decisions on whether to approve leave requests, it becomes difficult for an employee to establish a causal relationship between the request and subsequent disciplinary action. Require complete medical documentation. Ensure that any requests for medical leaves of absence are backed by sufficient, timely documentation. Failure of an employee to comply with a request for the required medical documentation by a deadline will provide a legally defensible practice.