Westchester
Marshall Dennehey established its Westchester County office - the firm's third office in New York State - in July 2014. Our key Westchester County location complements and expands upon the firm's existing offerings in Manhattan and Melville, Long Island.
Marshall Dennehey's expansion in New York is precipitated by the considerable growth of Westchester and the surrounding community as a regional commercial center over the past few decades. The county serves as a vibrant cross-section of business operations for numerous companies headquartered in Manhattan and across the Northeast corridor.
The Westchester office services clients in the county and throughout the entire New York Tri-State region. Staffed with attorneys in our Casualty, Health Care and Professional Liability Departments, the office's lawyers represent clients in all manner of civil defense litigation including premises, product and general liability; medical and dental malpractice defense; and professional liability matters.
Thought Leadership
Case Law Alerts
Virginia Federal Court Blocks U.S. DOT’s Attempt to Obtain 17 Million Commercial Driver Records from the American Association of Motor Vehicle Administrators
November 3, 2026
On August 13, 2026, in the Eastern District of Virginia, two coalitions of attorneys general from more than twenty states and the District of Columbia filed lawsuits seeking Temporary Restraining Orders against the the U.S. DOT, the Department of Homeland Security, and the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration to stop the American Association of Motor Vehicle Administrators (AAMVA) from turning over more than seventeen million commercial driver records. The AAMVA maintains the Commercial Driver’s License Information System (CDLIS) pursuant to its contract with the U.S. DOT. This system ensures that commercial driver’s license applicants only hold one driver’s license and possess only one complete driving record, which prevents the issuance of commercial driver’s licenses to applicants who have a recorded history of unsafe driving. The demand from the U.S. DOT sought the name, date of birth, state of record, license number, and Social Security Number for every driver in the CDLIS database for five years, as well as the date the Social Security Number was removed from the record if any record previously listed, but no longer had, a Social Security Number attached. Plaintiff states argue that the request violated privacy laws, while the federal government asserts that it is entitled to the records pursuant to the contract between the U.S. DOT and the AAMVA. The Court issued a Temporary Restraining Order on August 21, 2026. On September 17, 2026, the Court granted a preliminary injunction blocking the provision of the AAMVA records and ordered that the federal government is not permitted to take any adverse actions against the AAMVA, including previously threatened cancellation of grants and even the contract with the AAMVA to maintain the CDLIS. At present, without further action, the federal government does not and cannot have access to the AAMVA records sought.
Case Law Alerts
UPDATE: Supreme Court Issues Decision Exposing Freight Brokers to Liability For Negligent Hiring
November 3, 2026
In May 2026, with a unanimous 9-0 decision, the Supreme Court determined that the statutory protections provided by the Federal Aviation Administration Authorization Act (FAAAA) did not bar state law claims against freight brokers for negligent hiring. The FAAAA expressly preempts state regulations affecting prices, routes, and various services provided by freight carriers and brokers. However, the decision notes that the FAAAA contains a specific carveout which permits such state law claims. Specifically, the FAAAA provides for the states to preserve their own safety regulatory authority regarding motor vehicles. The Supreme Court interpreted this language to mean that while states did not have the authority to interfere with business operations of freight carriers and brokers, carrier selection by a broker is not a matter of business operations. Rather, the states have the authority to regulate roadway safety, and negligent hiring falls squarely within the state’s authority.
Results
Summary Judgment Won in Nearly Decade-Long Slip and Fall Case
We won summary judgment on nine-year-old supermarket slip and fall case. The plaintiff claimed that she tripped and fell on the corner of a pallet/box of watermelons in the defendant's produce section in Newburgh, New York, where customers first walk in. The plaintiff admitted she did not see the pallet or its corner and was not looking where she was walking. After her fall, she underwent multiple surgeries, including cervical fusion. Her attorney’s demand was $4 million. The defense motion argued that the watermelon pallet was a temporary merchandise display which was open and obvious to all to be seen with common sense. Indeed, customers walked by the pallet display before and after the plaintiff’s accident at a rate of dozens per day. The store put the watermelons out in this manner as part of its display policy because the melons are delivered in cartons on pallets that cannot be taken apart. The plaintiff argued in opposition that the pallet was a hazardous defect the store created and had notice of. The plaintiff submitted an expert engineer, who claimed the display violated American Society of Testing Materials’ (ASTM) designation F1637-10 regarding safe walkway surfaces. We submitted a rebuttal engineer, who demonstrated the ASTM standard asserted by the plaintiff applied to permanent structures—like floors and buildings—not the temporary pallet, and that the standard did not exist on the day of the accident. In granting summary judgment, the court concluded that while a landowner must act reasonably in maintaining its property in a reasonably safe condition, it is not an insurer of ordinary obstacles that are readily apparent as a matter of common sense and visibility.
Emotional Distress Claims Barred in Case Where Dog Was Run Over by Delivery Truck
The plaintiff pet owners brought claims of emotional/bystander distress and recklessness against the delivery service after personally witnessing the incident that tragically killed their family dog. We filed a Motion to Strike (equivalent of 12b(6) in State of Connecticut Superior Court, Judicial District of Fairfield at Bridgeport), citing appellate authority that, because dogs are personal property and bystander distress arises out of human-to-human relationships, plaintiffs were barred from alleging and recovering any kind of emotional distress damages. Only the fair market value purchase cost of the pet should be permitted. The plaintiffs cited recent trial court decisions allowing such claims and going against the grain of older appellate cases. After oral argument the court sided with the defense, agreeing that for important policy concerns the plaintiff cannot prevail because the plaintiffs were asking the court to legislate and make law beyond its authoritative powers.
News
Marshall Dennehey Named a 2027 Best Law Firm in Multiple Practice Areas by Best Lawyers®
November 5, 2026

106 Marshall Dennehey Attorneys Recognized in the 2027 Editions of The Best Lawyers in America® and the Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch® in America
August 20, 2026
Marshall Dennehey Again Earns Recognition in Distinguished Chambers USA
June 4, 2026
