Philadelphia
Located just blocks away from iconic City Hall, Marshall Dennehey is proud to call Philadelphia home. The growth and entrepreneurial spirit of our firm is paralleled by the innovative business spirit of Philadelphia, the epicenter of many life sciences, legal, energy, manufacturing, technology, financial, and biomedical and pharmaceutical enterprises.
The attorneys in our Philadelphia headquarters office represent a vast array of clients in civil litigation across virtually every practice area of the firm. We are leaders in the Philadelphia and Pennsylvania Bar Associations, the Philadelphia Association of Defense Counsel, the Lawyers’ Club of Philadelphia, the Insurance Society of Philadelphia and dozens of other regional, statewide and national legal and defense organizations.
We are deeply dedicated to the social, business, and charitable aspects of the Philadelphia metropolitan community and provide annual financial support to the United Way, the Philadelphia Bar Foundation, the Philadelphia Support Center for Child Advocates, and many other regional causes.
We invite you to visit us in Philadelphia, or in any of our 19 offices, where you will find an inclusive and winning corporate culture–we have been voted a “Best Places to Work” by the Philadelphia Business Journal for 14 consecutive years–and outstanding attorneys devoted to providing you with excellence in legal services.
Thought Leadership
Case Law Alerts
Pennsylvania Superior Court Affirms Summary Judgment on Failure-To-Warn Claim, Offers Helpful Illustration of “Deeding Presumption.”
November 3, 2026
This products liability case involved an allegedly defective walk-behind lawnmower that had been manufactured by the defendant. The plaintiff had purchased the lawnmower as a floor model, which did not come with an owner’s manual. The lawnmower did feature a prominent on-product label, though, which warned users about mowing on sloped areas. The plaintiff failed to heed the warning, slipped while mowing a sloped portion of his backyard, and suffered a mangled left foot. Plaintiff advanced claims of failure-to-warn and design defect. The former claim was dismissed at summary judgment; the latter returned a defense verdict at trial. On appeal, the Superior Court upheld the result, but spent most of its opinion discussing the warnings claim. In Pennsylvania, a plaintiff enjoys the benefit of a “heeding presumption” – a rebuttable presumption that, if an adequate warning has been provided, the plaintiff would have read and heeded it. (Some cases have held that the heeding presumption only applies in workplace asbestos cases. McDonnell did not mention or apply that limitation.) The heeding presumption serves to help establish the “causation” element of a failure-to-warn claim, i.e. that a different warning would have prevented the incident. The heeding presumption is rebuttable, though, upon evidence to the contrary. In McDonnell, the defendants pointed to the plaintiff’s own deposition testimony that he did not feel the need to track down a copy of the owner’s manual, or even spend time reading the on-product label. That was sufficient, the Superior Court held, to rebut the heeding presumption, and require Plaintiff to present affirmative evidence that a different warning would have made a difference. Plaintiff did not do so, and the Court found there was no basis to conclude that Plaintiff would have treated an alternative warning any differently than the current warnings he had ignored. Because Plaintiff could not establish the causation element of his failure-to-warn claim, the Superior Court affirmed the entry of summary judgment on that issue. Helpfully, the Court also re-affirmed the corollary heeding presumption in favor of product sellers: “Where the given warnings are sufficient to make a product safe for its intended use, a plaintiff cannot recover for injuries sustained as a result of his failure to heed them, for manufacturers and sellers are also entitled to a presumption that consumers will heed it.” Ultimately, McDonnell is a good illustration of the shifting burdens that apply in a failure-to-warn claim.
Case Law Alerts
The “Newlin” Case: Implications for Long-Term Care Management Companies
November 3, 2026
On August 4, 2026 the Pennsylvania Supreme Court issued a ruling via a 2-1 majority opinion on hotly contested area of Pennsylvania healthcare law with major implications on long-term health care handling. See Newlin v. Vita Healthcare Group, 2026 Pa. Super. LEXIS 408 (2026). For the purposes of this article, the main holdings relate to whether long-term care management companies can he held liable under a theory of direct corporate liability pursuant to Thompson v. Nason Hospital, 527 Pa. 330, 591 A.2d 703 (Pa. 1991) and its progeny. Case Facts and Procedural History: This matter arose from alleged nursing home negligence brought by the Estate of Patricia O'Donnell following her death in August 5, 2019 at Riddle Hospital allegedly due to multi organ failure due to septic shock caused by infection to a large sacral decubitus pressure ulcer as well as hydromorphone intoxication. The alleged negligence related to a history of falls and pressure related injuries during Ms. O’Donnell’s residency at Brinton Manor March 28, 2018 through July 21, 2019. Relevant to her residency, BM-SNF purchased Brinton Manor from Genesis and contracted with Vita to manage the facility. On July 1, 2019, 21 days prior to Decedent's final day of residency at Brinton Manor, BM Rehab purchased Brinton Manor from BM-SNF and Imperial assumed management responsibilities. On February 2, 2023, the jury returned a verdict of $4,000,000 in compensatory damages in favor of the Estate. Specifically, the jury awarded the Estate: (1) $600,000 from BM-SNF; (2) $2,400,000 from Vita; (3) $800,000 from BM Rehab; and (4) $200,000 from Imperial. In addition, the trial court awarded punitive damages in the amount of $15,000,000 as follows: (1) $5,000,000 against BM-SNF; $6,500,000 against Vita; (3) $2,000,000 against BM Rehab; and (4) $1,500,000 against Imperial. On February 6, 2023, Defendants filed post-trial motions. Vital to the appeal, Plaintiff’s counsel informed the court during a June 6, 2026 hearing that the Estate was only pursuing a theory of corporate negligence against the management company Defendants, and not pursuing a claim of negligence based on vicarious liability. This was in spite of arguing corporate liability claims against all defendants at trial. Against the Operating Company Defendants, the Estate informed the trial court that it was only pursuing a claim of vicarious liability. On this basis, the trial court granted a motion JNOV as it related to the management companies because the Scampone line of cases precluded the Estate as a matter of law from establishing corporate liability against the management company Defendants. Thus, they were entitled to JNOV as a matter of law. The court also remitted the punitive damages award against BM Rehab from $2,000,000 to $385,000. Following the entry of judgment, the parties filed appeals and cross-appeals. Superior Court Opinion Pertaining to Corporate Liability for Management Companies: Initially, the Pennsylvania Superior court noted that “The Supreme Court agreed that a nursing home could be subject to corporate liability, holding that "a nursing home and affiliated entities are subject to potential direct liability for negligence, where the requisite resident-entity relationship exists to establish that the entity owes the resident a duty of care." See Scampone v. Highland Park Care Center, LLC, 618 Pa. 363, 57 A.3d 582, 584 (Pa. 2012). Moreover, the Superior court cited to the non-precedential opinion of Hopkins v. Compass Point Healthcare System, LLC 262 A.3d 471, 2021 WL 3465831 at *6 (Pa. Super. filed 2021) stating: “…as a matter of law, when it is only the operator of a nursing home that has the contractual relationship with the plaintiff, only the operator of the nursing home can be held liable under a theory of corporate liability, even if the operator delegates the performance of its Thompson duties to a management company…” Holding that the trial court did not err in finding that there could be no theory of corporate liability for the management company, the Superior court focused on the fact that there was no contractual relationship between the decedent, the decedent’s estate, and the Management Company Defendants. In so holding, the Superior court also noted that the Scampone line of cases previously established that the key determination is the contractual relationship between the parties and “[o]nce that entity assumes those duties, that entity is still liable even if it delegates the performance of those duties to a different entity.” (See Scampone III, 169 A.3d at 608). While the court did not close the door on a Plaintiff’s ability to seek vicarious liability theories against a Management Company, the court refused to consider the same as Plaintiff had expressly abandoned those claims, as stated during the post-trial motions hearing. Outside of this instant holding, the Superior court remanded the matter to determine the amount of compensatory damages to which the Estate is entitled from the Operating Company Defendant. It is anticipated that there will be additional appeals to this matter and the case remains one to be monitored.
Results
News
Marshall Dennehey Announces 2027 Pennsylvania Super Lawyers and Rising Stars Honorees
November 9, 2026

Marshall Dennehey Named a 2027 Best Law Firm in Multiple Practice Areas by Best Lawyers®
November 5, 2026

Global Leadership Expert India Gary-Martin Speaks at Marshall Dennehey’s Annual DE&I Attorney Meeting
September 18, 2026
