Advertising Disclosure Email Disclosure

Pennsylvania Supreme Court rejects Commonwealth Court's extension of Political Subdivision Tort Claims Act to all statutory claims and limits the scope of the Act to claims sounding in tort.

October 1, 2010
Meyer v. Community College of Beaver County, 2010 Pa. LEXIS 1802 (Pa. 2010)

The impact of a pair of decisions issued by the Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court in 2008, which vastly expanded the scope of governmental immunity to all claims, tort or contract, has been short lived. In Meyer, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, in a unanimous decision issued on August 17, 2010, overturned two decisions by the Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court which granted summary judgment to a community college. In doing so, the Supreme Court reaffirmed its position that the Political Subdivision Tort Claims Act (“PSTCA”) applies only to claims sounding in tort and does not confer immunity to local agencies for contract based claims. The two underlying civil cases were companion claims involving two groups of former students who were enrolled in a police training program and had completed a substantial portion of the training when the college lost its certification. As a result of the loss of accreditation, the students claimed that the course work which was already completed and paid for was not transferable to another college. The students sued the community college, a local agency under the PSTCA, and claimed breach of contract, warranty and claims under Pennsylvania’s Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law (“UTPCPL”). The college sought dismissal of the UTPCPL claims on the basis that the claims sought tort remedies, were subject to governmental immunity, and did not fall within any of the exceptions to immunity set forth within the PSTCA. The trial court disagreed with the characterization of the UTPCPL as being based in tort and, instead, ruled that as the law protected consumer expectations, a claim under the Act was more contractual in nature and thus governmental immunity conferred by the PSTCA did not apply. The Commonwealth Court granted review of the decisions and overturned the trial court and determined that the college was entitled to immunity from the claims. The majority holdings were based on the court’s determination that local agencies are immune from all statutory causes of action, whether arising in contract or tort, as long as they do not implicate any of the eight exceptions to governmental immunity. The Supreme Court accepted review and overturned the Commonwealth Court’s decision. In doing so, the Court described the Commonwealth Court’s decision as ”not sustainable” and, to the extent that its reasoning was adopted, it would impair the enforceability of contractual relationships with the government. Such a result would have unintended effects which, in the words of the Court, "are best to be avoided." The Court ruled that the immunity provided to local agencies under the PSTCA applied to tort claims only and not claims sounding in contract, whether statutorily based or otherwise.

Case Law Alert - 4t Qtr 2010

Affiliated Attorney

Paul G. Lees
Shareholder
(484) 895-2321
pglees@mdwcg.com

Practice Areas

Before you send this email please note:

You are attempting to send email, through a link on our website, to an attorney of Marshall Dennehey Warner Coleman & Goggin or an employee in our firm. Please note that your email may not be treated as confidential and does not create an attorney-client relationship. You should not rely upon the transmission of an email through this website if you are seeking to enter into such a relationship. Until such time as we have agreed to represent you, no information in your email will be treated as confidential. Please contact us directly by telephone at 1.800.220.3308 if it is your intent to seek legal counsel with our firm or convey confidential information.

If it is still your intent to send this email, knowing that it may not be treated as confidential, you may accept our terms of agreement by pressing "OK". If you choose not to accept these terms of agreement you may navigate away from this page by pressing "Cancel."